Diaper Stats and Reviews

Here are two tables that contains the scores collected so far on diapers. These are all of the diapers that have received at least 20 survey responses. If you do not see a diaper on here that you want to see a review on, then please encourage people to fill out surveys on the diapers (you can go to forums, fanpages, etc.)

Table 1: Sorted by Baby Type

Diaper	Everyone	Heavy Wetter	Chunky	Chunky Thighs	Skinny	Skinny Thighs	Rash Prone
Applecheeks 2-Size AI2/Pocket Diaper	83	79	85	79	82	87	77
Bottom Bumpers Side Snapping AIO (Sized)*	64	68	69	68	61	60	69
Bumgenius 4.0 Pocket Diaper*	82	81	78	81	84	83	82
Bumgenius Elemental	86	89	90	86	90	87	74
Fuzzibunz One Size Pocket Diaper*	71	69	82	72	63	47	74
Fuzzibunz Perfect Size Pocket Diaper*	77	78	89	88	60	66	78
GroVia One Size AIO*	73	75	71	71	81	84	74
Gro Via One Size AI2*	73	74	64	70	78	81	76
Kawaii Baby Heavy Duty One Size Pocket Diaper*	83	81	84	86	78	76	79
Oh Katy One Size Pocket Diaper	90	87	92	94	***96***	85	88
Rocky Mountain One Size Pocket Diaper	75	75	73	78	78	74	80
Rumparooz One Size Pocket Diaper*	73	75	75	75	77	69	83
Softbums Omni One Size AI2/Pocket Diaper	91	92	93	93	92	94	88
Tiny Tush One Size Pocket Diaper	86	87	88	84	84	86	84

Table 2: Sorted By Items Such as Fit, Trim, Absorbency, etc

Diaper	Absorbency	Fit	Worth Price	Trim	Liked by Skeptics	Nap	Night***	Would Recom'd
Applecheeks 2 size AI2/Pocket Diaper	88	92	83	81	88	85	51	93
Bottom Bumpers Side Snapping AIO (Sized)*	76	88	76	90	43	48	14	76
Bumgenius 4.0 One Size Pocket Diaper*	83	86	86	63	93	90	48	87
Bumgenius Elemental	85	86	59	81	85	78	30	86
Fuzzibunz One Size Pocket Diaper*	78	77	77	75	69	71	46	79
Fuzzibunz Perfect Size Pocket Diaper*	78	77	83	83	83	74	57	83
GroVia One Size AIO*	74	84	87	89	77	81	28	66
Gro Via One Size AI2*	75	83	79	77	81	69	29	84
Kawaii Baby Heavy Duty One Size Pocket Diaper*	92	73	90	52	90	90	81	89
Oh Katy One Size Pocket Diaper	88	91	97	84	88	93	83	98
Rocky Mountain One Size Pocket Diaper	76	79	78	87	78	84	49	78
Rumparooz One Size Pocket Diaper*	84	74	55	62	79	87	57	77
Softbums Omni One Size AI2/Pocket Diaper	91	95	90	81	86	96	86	99
Tiny Tush One Size Pocket Diaper	83	89	90	69	81	90	80	95

* Diapers asterisked were scored on a Yes/No scale. The newly released surveys score on a 1-5 scale, therefore you will see a slight difference in scoring. I have since revised the surveys for those diapers and as soon as I get 20 responses I will replace the scores with those of a 1-5 scale. If you filled out the Yes/No survey (any prior to 7/14), then feel free to go back and fill out the new survey. Contact me if you have any questions (like determining which survey you filled out).

** Diapers not included in this that did receive 20 survey responses were Ragababe AIOs, Ragababe 2-Steps, Softbums Echo, Greenline Diapers, and Bumgenius Flips. These were the first three surveys that I did and therefore the results are not comparable to the new version. I have since updated the surveys for these and as soon as I receive 20 responses I will post the results.
*** I feel it is important to clarify that many survey respondents weren't sure whether "night use" was meant with the diaper "as sold" or if it meant "with the addition of ____ insert." I wrote it with the intention of meaning it could be made to work with certain inserts, which is why there was also the question about what inserts people used to make it work. Therefore, I assume MOST people read the survey that way. But you might also assume many didn't. The newer versions of my survey will distinguish between "as is" use and "as modified" use.


Diaper Award Recipients

The recipients of the Golden Diaper Awards received scores of 95 or higher

Click to enlarge

Completed Reviews
Click on the links below to see the reviews that have been completed. I will still take survey responses for these diapers and may revisit the review later:

Statistical Reviews
Applecheeks 2-size Pocket/AI2 Diaper System
BumGenius 4.0 One Size Pocket Diaper
BumGenius Elemental One Size Diaper
DryBees AIO Hybrid Diaper 
Flip Diapering System 
Green Line All in Two Diaper  
GroVia One Size AIO 
Oh Katy One Size Pocket Diaper
Ragababe 'Easy' All in One Diaper
Ragababe Organic 2-Step Diaper
Rocky Mountain Diapers Review
Softbums Echo Review
Softbums Omni Review
Tiny Tush Elite One Size Pocket Diaper

My Reviews
Best Bottom One Size All in Two Diaper
Dinkledooz One Size Pocket Diaper
Gro Via Newborn AIO
Itti Bitti D'lish
Little Boppers All in Two Diaper
Little Boppers Fitted Diaper
Mother-ease Sandy's Fitted Diaper
Rainshine Designs Newborn AIO
Sunbaby 4.0 One Size Pocket Diaper